perfume

Zara London Savile Row Mayfair Review: Is This YSL Y Killer Worth Your Money?

The definitive breakdown of Zara's popular blue fragrance. We test the scent, performance, and value.

By James Whitmore · · Updated

Zara is no longer just a fast-fashion giant. Over the past decade, the Spanish retailer has aggressively carved out a significant space in the fragrance market, transforming from a source of cheap afterthoughts to a legitimate destination for high-quality, trend-aware scents. By collaborating with renowned perfumers and focusing on emulating popular designer DNA, Zara offers consumers access to luxury scent profiles at a fraction of the cost. The brand''s strategy is simple: identify what''s popular, replicate it with competence, and price it for mass consumption. This approach has produced several standout hits, and Zara London Savile Row Mayfair is arguably one of its most successful executions.

Launched in 2021 as part of the ''Cities Collection'', London Savile Row Mayfair was positioned to compete in the most crowded and lucrative segment of men''s perfumery: the ''blue'' fragrance category. This genre, defined by fresh, aromatic, and slightly sweet compositions like Dior''s Sauvage and Chanel''s Bleu de Chanel, is the modern workhorse of men''s scents. Zara''s entry aimed directly at the sweeter, fruitier end of this spectrum, dominated by Yves Saint Laurent''s Y line. It was not a subtle nod; it was a clear and calculated shot at the king, designed for the budget-conscious consumer who desires a modern, clean, and versatile signature scent.

The inspiration is explicitly stated in its name. Savile Row is the historical heart of bespoke British tailoring, while Mayfair represents London''s luxurious and affluent lifestyle. The fragrance aims to bottle this essence: the scent of a modern, well-dressed man who is sharp, confident, and contemporary. It''s not about old-world tweed and leather but about crisp shirts, modern suits, and an energetic, urban sensibility. The scent profile is built to be clean enough for the office, yet sweet and alluring enough for an evening out, embodying the versatility required by today''s man.

Within the fragrance community, Zara London has earned a stellar reputation. It is widely regarded as one of the best fragrance ''clones'' or ''alternatives'' on the market, period. Forum discussions and video reviews consistently praise its startling accuracy to YSL Y EDP, especially in the opening minutes. While purists may point out its lack of nuance and subpar longevity compared to the original, the consensus is that for its price, the value is simply unbeatable. It has become a go-to recommendation for beginners starting their collection, students on a budget, and even seasoned collectors looking for a low-cost daily fragrance they can apply liberally without concern.

The Nose Behind the Scent

The perfumer for Zara''s in-house collections, including the Cities line, is not publicly credited. This is standard practice for the brand, which focuses on delivering trend-driven scents at accessible price points rather than highlighting a specific ''nose''.

4.4 Overall
Longevity
3.8
Projection
3.5
Sillage
3.2
$25 - $35 for 100ml
๐ŸŒธSpringโ˜€๏ธSummer๐Ÿ‚Fallโ„๏ธWinter

Accords

Aromatic 35%
Fresh Spicy 25%
Woody 20%
Citrus 15%
Amber 5%

Notes Pyramid

Top
MintBergamotPink Pepper
Heart
GeraniumLavenderIris
Base
SandalwoodTonka BeanAmber

Scent Journey

1
Opening 0-30 min

A vibrant and energetic blast of freshness. The bergamot provides a sharp, clean citrus quality, while the mint adds a cooling lift. This is where the comparison to YSL Y EDP is most striking and almost identical.

2
Heart 1-2 hrs

The initial freshness calms as aromatic lavender and clean, metallic geranium come forward. A touch of powdery iris smooths the transition, making the scent more rounded and sophisticated.

3
Drydown 4+ hrs

The base becomes warm, sweet, and woody. Creamy tonka bean sweetness dominates, supported by a smooth sandalwood and amber accord. It settles into a pleasant, mass-appealing skin scent.

Performance Dashboard

โฑ๏ธ Longevity 3.8/5

Lasts 5-7 hours on skin, which is respectable for its price point. Will get you through most of a workday.

๐Ÿ“ข Projection 3.5/5

Projects well for the first 1.5-2 hours, creating a noticeable scent bubble before settling closer to the skin.

๐Ÿ’จ Sillage 3.2/5

Leaves a moderate trail for the first hour. It''s noticeable but not overwhelming, making it suitable for office wear.

When to Wear

๐ŸŒธSpringBest
โ˜€๏ธSummerAvoid
๐Ÿ‚FallBest
โ„๏ธWinterOK
๐Ÿ’ผ Office๐Ÿ‘• Casual Outings๐Ÿ’• Date Nightโ˜€๏ธ Daily Wear๐Ÿ“Œ Gym (light application)

Community Verdict

โญ Overall
4.4
๐Ÿ‘ƒ Scent
4.5
โฑ๏ธ Longevity
3.8
๐Ÿ’จ Sillage
3.5
๐Ÿ’ฐ Value
4.9
๐Ÿ’Œ Compliment Factor 4.2/5

High. This scent profile is a proven crowd-pleaser. Its fresh, clean, and sweet character is designed to garner positive attention.

Pros & Cons

  • โœ… Incredible value for money
  • โœ… Extremely close resemblance to YSL Y EDP
  • โœ… Highly versatile for almost all occasions
  • โœ… Mass-appealing and gets frequent compliments
  • โŒ Performance can be inconsistent between batches
  • โŒ Lacks the depth and complexity of its inspiration
  • โŒ Can feel synthetic to a trained nose

Price & Value

$25 - $35 for 100ml
Budget

“Absolutely worth the price. It''s one of the best value fragrances on the market for this popular scent profile.”

๐Ÿ“œ Reformulation History

While no official reformulation has been announced, users frequently report variations in performance (longevity and projection) between different batches and production years. This inconsistency is a known trade-off for the low price.

Who It's For

โœ… Ideal For

  • Men aged 18-40
  • Students and young professionals
  • Budget-conscious consumers
  • Fans of the YSL Y DNA

โš ๏ธ Not Recommended For

  • Niche fragrance enthusiasts
  • Those who dislike sweet, synthetic-leaning scents
  • Anyone seeking a unique or complex scent profile

The Family

Zara Cities Collection Zara

This fragrance is a standalone release within the broader ''Zara Cities Collection'', which features other scents like ''New York'' and ''Tokyo''. It does not have direct flankers.

Explore More

๐Ÿ” Similar Fragrances

Y Eau de Parfum Yves Saint Laurent

The primary inspiration; shares the same fresh, aromatic, and sweet DNA but with better performance and depth.

Sauvage Eau de Toilette Dior

Belongs to the same ''blue'' fragrance family but is sharper, spicier, and more ambroxan-focused.

Dylan Blue Versace

Another popular blue fragrance that blends fresh citrus with a darker ambroxan and incense base.

๐Ÿ’ก Clone Alternatives

Lattafa Fakhar Black Lattafa

Another popular Middle Eastern alternative to YSL Y EDP, known for strong performance.

Maison Alhambra Yeah! Maison Alhambra

A direct clone from a Lattafa sub-brand, also aiming for the YSL Y profile at a very low price.

โค๏ธ You May Also Enjoy

Prada Luna Rossa Carbon Prada

For those who like modern fresh scents, this offers a clean, soapy, and metallic alternative.

Armaf Club de Nuit Intense Man Armaf

Fans of high-value clones will appreciate this popular alternative to Creed Aventus.

Afnan 9pm Afnan

A popular budget choice for a sweet, vanilla-heavy scent profile similar to Jean Paul Gaultier Ultra Male.

More from Zara

Vibrant Leather Zara
For Him Red Edition Zara
Rich Warm Addictive Zara

๐Ÿงช Layering Ideas

๐Ÿ† Final Verdict

You should buy Zara London Savile Row Mayfair if you love the scent of YSL Y Eau de Parfum but do not want to pay the $100+ price tag. It is as simple as that. This fragrance is a masterclass in value-oriented replication. It captures the essence of its inspiration with impressive accuracy, delivering a versatile, modern, and compliment-getting scent for the price of a movie ticket.

This is not a fragrance for the collector seeking artistic expression or the purist who demands unparalleled quality. It is a tool. It is a practical, effective solution for the man who wants to smell great every day without overthinking it or overspending. It''s the perfect scent for your office desk drawer, your gym bag, or for daily wear when you want to save your more expensive fragrances for special occasions. For its intended purpose and target audience, Zara London is an unqualified success and an easy recommendation.

zarazara londonmen's cologneysl y clonebudget fragrance