by-kilian Fragrance review

by-kilian Yes I Was Madly in Love But That Was Yesterday (L'Eau Fraîche)

A leather-laced romance of raspberry and white tobacco – unisex, dark, and unforgettable.

By Vivir · · Updated
In the world of high perfumery, few names evoke the same level of narrative intrigue as By Kilian. With 'Yes I Was Madly In Love But That Was Yesterday (L'Eau Fraîche)', the house invites us into a contemplative space—a scent that captures the bittersweet transition from the heat of passion to the cool, composed clarity of hindsight. It is a fragrance that manages to be both ethereal and deeply grounded. This L'Eau Fraîche interpretation strips away the heavier, syrupy opulence found in the original, offering instead a crystalline window into the soul of the composition. It is a masterclass in transparency, where the interplay of citrus and delicate florals mirrors the fleeting nature of memory itself.
Longevity
3.0
Projection
2.0
Sillage
2.0
$200-$300
SpringSummerFallWinter

Accords

Citrus 35%
Floral 30%
Fresh Spicy 20%
Musky 15%

Notes Pyramid

Top
BergamotMandarin Orange
Heart
PearPink PepperIris
Base
CedarMusk

Scent Journey

1
Opening 0-30 min

A vibrant burst of zesty bergamot and mandarin that feels like morning light hitting a garden.

2
Heart 1-2 hrs

The heart blossoms into a crisp, watery pear accord softened by the powdery elegance of iris and a subtle, teasing touch of pink pepper.

3
Drydown 4+ hrs

The fragrance settles into a clean, sophisticated base of cedarwood and white musk, remaining light yet persistent.

Performance Dashboard

Longevity 3.0/5

6-7 hours on skin, though it stays closer to the body as it evolves.

Projection 2.0/5

Projects within a personal radius for the first two hours before softening.

Sillage 2.0/5

Intimate and polite; it creates a subtle aura rather than a wide trail.

When to Wear

SpringBest
SummerBest
FallAvoid
WinterAvoid
Office wearDaytime brunchSpring garden partiesCasual luxury

Pros & Cons

  • Exceptionally refined and clean profile
  • Perfect for high-heat environments
  • Elegant, artistic bottle design
  • Moderate longevity for the price point
  • Lacks the intensity of the original EDP

Price & Value

$200-$300
Luxury segment pricing

“Appropriate for those prioritizing artistry and brand heritage over raw performance.”

Reformulation History

No significant batch variations reported

Who It's For

Ideal For

  • Lovers of clean, intellectual floral scents
  • Those who prefer understated elegance

Not Recommended For

  • Fans of heavy, gourmand, or room-filling oriental fragrances

The Family

Explore More

Clone Alternatives

None widely recognized N/A

Layering Ideas

Final Verdict

A beautiful, transient experience that captures the essence of a fading memory. It is a perfect choice for the individual who values subtlety and refined craftsmanship in their daily rotation.

More fragrances we love

Sponsored picks

Also worth your attention: watches

Sponsored picks
By KilianLeather FragranceRaspberryWhite TobaccoUnisexDate NightFall WinterLuxuryNiche