Lush Pumpkin Spice Review: A Savory, Smoky Body Spray

Pumpkin spice has become a cultural phenomenon, synonymous with cozy autumn days, oversized sweaters, and sweet, creamy lattes. But Lush's 2025 release, Pumpkin Spice, flips that narrative on its head. This is not a bakery gourmand; it's a savory, spicy, resinous body spray that smells more like a simmering pot of spiced chai or a smoky boba tea than a pumpkin pie. Built on an unusual quartet of clove, ginger, carrot seed, and carob resinoid, it's a fragrance that challenges expectations and has sparked heated debate among fragrance enthusiasts. In a world where sweet gourmands dominate the fall fragrance landscape, Lush Pumpkin Spice dares to be different. It's polarizing, potent, and unapologetically unique. With a community rating of just 2.59/5 on Fragrantica, it's clearly not for everyone – but for those who appreciate a savory twist on spice, it might just be a hidden gem. In this review, we'll dive into the notes, performance, and the cultural context surrounding this controversial release, helping you decide if it deserves a spot in your collection.