Ralph Lauren Polo Supreme Leather Review: The Discontinued King of Designer Leather
Ralph Lauren, a brand synonymous with American preppy style, took a significant step into the luxury fragrance market in 2015 with its Polo Supreme collection. This trio of scents—Oud, Cashmere, and the subject of today''s review, Leather—was a clear move to capture the attention of consumers developing more sophisticated palates, influenced by the rise of niche perfumery and Middle Eastern scent profiles. Polo Supreme Leather was positioned not as another fresh, sporty cologne, but as a refined, opulent and mature fragrance designed for the discerning gentleman. It was a departure from the brand’s typical offerings, aiming for a seat at the table with more premium designer lines.
The concept behind Supreme Leather was to create a scent that was both powerful and elegant, capturing the essence of a soft, well-worn leather jacket. The inspiration draws from classic masculine archetypes: the adventurer, the scholar, the refined gentleman. It eschews the raw, animalic leather notes found in some niche creations, opting instead for a smoother, sweeter, and spicier interpretation. This makes it more approachable than its hardcore niche counterparts, serving as a perfect bridge for those looking to graduate from mainstream designer scents into something with more character and depth.
Crafted by the legendary perfumer Carlos Benaim, the fragrance was designed to be a statement piece. It wasn''t meant to blend in. The blend of warm spices, rich leather, and a gourmand base of honey and tonka bean was both bold and inviting. It was a fragrance that announced its presence with confidence but spoke with a sophisticated, measured tone. The quality of the ingredients and the masterful blending were immediately apparent, setting it apart from the rest of the Polo lineup.
Unfortunately, like many ambitious designer releases, Polo Supreme Leather was discontinued, much to the dismay of its dedicated followers. This has elevated its status from a premium designer offering to a sought-after collector''s item. Its reputation in the fragrance community is stellar; it is often cited as one of the best designer leather fragrances ever created and a prime example of a brand successfully executing a high-concept, niche-quality scent. Today, finding a bottle requires some searching, but for those who appreciate a masterfully blended spicy leather, the hunt is often worth the reward.
The Nose Behind the Scent
Carlos Benaim, a master perfumer and recipient of the Fragrance Foundation''s Lifetime Achievement Award. His notable creations include Viktor & Rolf Flowerbomb, Calvin Klein Eternity for Men, and the original Ralph Lauren Polo.
Accords
Notes Pyramid
Scent Journey
A potent and warm blast of sweet spices. The cardamom and nutmeg are rich and inviting, setting a sophisticated tone from the very first spray. The leather note is already detectable, waiting in the wings.
The leather accord takes center stage, but it''s a soft, supple suede, not a harsh, animalic leather. Saffron adds a touch of earthy luxury, while the spices from the opening provide a warm, supportive backdrop. The honey note begins to emerge, adding sweetness.
The fragrance settles into a creamy, gourmand base. The honey and tonka bean create a smooth, warm, and slightly powdery finish. The leather and spices become a soft, sensual skin scent that lasts for hours.
Performance Dashboard
Excellent longevity. Lasts a full 8-10 hours on skin and can linger on clothes for several days.
Projects strongly for the first 2-3 hours, creating a noticeable scent bubble of about 3-4 feet before settling closer to the skin.
Leaves a moderate to strong, captivating trail. It''s noticeable and alluring without being overwhelming or intrusive.
When to Wear
Community Verdict
Receives consistent, positive attention. Its unique yet appealing blend of spice and sweet leather is often complimented in social and intimate settings.
Pros & Cons
- ✅ Masterfully blended, niche-quality scent profile
- ✅ Excellent longevity and solid performance
- ✅ Sophisticated and masculine without being aggressive
- ✅ Considered one of the best designer leather fragrances ever made
- ✅ High compliment factor
- ❌ Discontinued and very difficult to find
- ❌ Extremely high price on the secondary/resale market
- ❌ Sweetness may be too much for some purist leather fans
- ❌ Not versatile for all seasons or occasions
Price & Value
“Originally a good value, its current price makes it a luxury purchase. It is worth the price only for dedicated collectors or those who consider it their ''holy grail'' scent.”
📜 Reformulation History
No significant batch variations are widely reported. The primary issue is its discontinued status, making any available bottle a rare find. Consistency was generally high during its production run.
Who It's For
✅ Ideal For
- Men aged 25+
- Individuals with a sophisticated and classic style
- Lovers of warm, spicy, and sweet leather scents
- Someone looking for a signature cold-weather fragrance
⚠️ Not Recommended For
- Anyone seeking a fresh, light, or aquatic fragrance
- Use in hot weather or enclosed office spaces
- Those on a tight budget, due to its discontinued status and high secondary market price
The Family
Part of the original 2015 ''Supreme'' collection, focusing on a rich, spicy oud accord.
The third member of the ''Supreme'' trio, a soft, warm, and comforting scent centered on cashmere and orris.
Explore More
🔍 Similar Fragrances
Shares a prominent leather note, but is harsher, smokier, and features a raspberry accord.
A brighter, citrus-led leather that is more suited for daytime wear.
A sweeter, boozy leather with a prominent whiskey note, making it more of a ''night out'' scent.
💡 Clone Alternatives
Often compared to Tuscan Leather, but its blend of saffron, raspberry, and leather shares a similar opulent vibe with Supreme Leather at a lower price point.
While a clone of a different fragrance, its rich blend of sweet and spicy notes can appeal to the same audience that enjoys the gourmand aspects of Supreme Leather.
❤️ You May Also Enjoy
Features a sophisticated blend of leather and iris, appealing to those who like elegant, powerful scents.
For those who love the warm, spicy, and sweet elements of Supreme Leather.
A popular designer scent with a smooth leather note combined with vanilla and iris.
More from Ralph Lauren
🧪 Layering Ideas
- A simple vanilla fragrance to amplify the honey and tonka bean in the base.
- A molecule scent like Iso E Super to add a woody, ethereal diffusion to the composition.
- A light tobacco fragrance to create an even richer, more complex ''gentleman''s club'' aroma.
🏆 Final Verdict
Ralph Lauren Polo Supreme Leather is a casualty of a market that sometimes prioritizes mass-market appeal over artisanal quality. It is a masterfully blended fragrance that stands as one of the best designer leather scents of the last decade. Its composition is a perfect harmony of warm spice, smooth leather, and delectable sweetness, resulting in a scent that is sophisticated, masculine, and deeply alluring.
Should you buy it? If you can find a bottle at a price you''re comfortable with and you love warm, spicy, sweet leather fragrances, the answer is an unequivocal yes. It''s a modern classic that represents a high point for the Ralph Lauren fragrance house. For those on a budget, exploring some of the similar fragrances mentioned is a more practical approach. But for those who want the real thing, Polo Supreme Leather remains a gold standard.