Imaginary Authors Fragrance review
Imaginary Authors The Hall Of Hallucination Review
Honeyed myrrh, opium smoke and gilded musk: Josh Meyer's rarest chapter yet

In this review
Accords
Notes Pyramid
Scent Journey
The first thirty minutes are the most confrontational and the most memorable. Honey and manuka arrive together, thick and dark, with myrrh's medicinal bitterness threading through them. For roughly ten minutes the sweetness is genuinely loud, almost syrupy, and the smoke has not yet emerged to balance it. There is no citrus, no aromatic lift, no traditional head accord — the fragrance begins at full weight. This is the phase that divides opinion, and it is decisive: if you dislike honey in perfume, nothing that follows will redeem it.
Between one and two hours the composition opens out. The opium accord becomes legible — balsamic, abstractly floral, with a narcotic softness that resists literal description. Fir injects a cool green-resinous countercurrent, like fresh air moving through a closed room, while suede emerges beneath to give the middle a soft, matte, almost tactile quality. This is the most balanced phase of the fragrance and, for many wearers, its high point: sweet and smoky in roughly equal measure, with the resin holding the centre steady.
From four hours onward the base takes over, and it is where the fragrance becomes genuinely beautiful. Smoke moves to the foreground — soft, grey, sweet woodsmoke rather than anything acrid — and settles over a clean musk foundation. Myrrh returns, closing the circle opened in the first thirty seconds, and the Gold facet appears as a faint metallic shimmer, cool and slightly mineral, hovering above the warmth. The final hours are quiet, resinous and faintly melancholy: the smell of a room after the fire has burned down.
Performance Dashboard
Typically 6-8 hours, but the spread is wide. Honey-dominant wears on warm skin have been reported to last all day, past the ten-hour mark; smoke-forward wears can fade to a skin scent by hour five or six.
Moderate to strong. Two to three sprays is ample for an evening; four or more in an enclosed space will be noticed by everyone in the room.
Moderate to heavy. In the first two hours it fills the space immediately around the wearer without becoming oppressive, then moderates into a warm resinous aura clearly detectable at conversational distance.
When to Wear
Pros & Cons
- A genuinely novel construction combining honey, myrrh, suede and smoke in a way few houses attempt
- High-quality materials with a clear and sustained resinous through-line
- Excellent cold-weather performance with meaningful projection and presence
- A strong conceptual and presentational identity consistent with the house's literary method
- A drydown that rewards patience with real depth and beauty
- A fixed $200 price for 50ml with no sampling option and no smaller format
- Variable longevity across wears depending on which facet the skin amplifies
- A divisive, loud honeyed opening that will lose some wearers before the heart arrives
- Limited availability through the 4th Floor loyalty programme, making it effectively inaccessible to casual buyers
Price & Value
“Fair value for the committed collector, poor value for the curious. If you already know and trust the house's resinous output, the price is defensible. If you are approaching Imaginary Authors for the first time, start elsewhere.”
Reformulation History
No significant batch variations have been reported. The release is recent and produced in small runs, which makes large-scale formula drift unlikely. The more probable source of bottle-to-bottle difference is maceration time, since young bottles of resin-heavy compositions often smell tighter and sweeter than bottles that have rested for several months. Given the fragrance's already variable performance, allowing a new bottle to settle before judging it is a reasonable precaution.
Who It's For
Ideal For
- Collectors of resinous ambers and balsamic orientals
- Wearers who already love honey and myrrh in perfumery
- Those who buy fragrance for themselves rather than for compliments
- Anyone who appreciates a composition with a difficult first act and a genuine arc
- Existing Imaginary Authors customers who followed the smoky-sweet line from Memoirs of a Trespasser onward
Not Recommended For
- Anyone who dislikes sweet and smoky profiles in equal measure
- Warm-weather minimalists and wearers who prefer fresh, clean signatures
- Buyers who require a sample before committing, given the absence of a sampling option
- Office wearers in close quarters
- Anyone seeking a conventionally elegant, low-risk signature scent
Explore More
Similar Fragrances
The Abandoned Mansion
Imaginary Authors
You May Also Enjoy
Layering Ideas
- Apply a single spray of a smoky birch-tar or incense-dominant fragrance to the chest to amplify the base and push the composition further toward its charred side.
- Layer over a dry vetiver or a mineral incense soliflore to cut the honey's opening sweetness and bring the fir and suede forward.
- Avoid layering with fresh citruses or aquatic materials — they collapse the resin structure and leave the fragrance smelling thin.
- If the opening reads too sweet, apply to fabric rather than skin; this slows the honey's development and lets the smoke arrive sooner.
Chergui
Ambre Narguile
Back to Black
Bois d'Armenie
Mind Games
Narcotica Maniac
Measuse Wondrous Flight
Impassable Wilderness
Dipped in Chocolate
Blend No 83